Since the Giants’ first season in 1925, they’ve had a slew of standout players. A large number of the Giants’ former football players have gone on to achieve legendary status in their respective sports. The Pro Football Hall of Fame has inducted 29 former “Big Blue” players. It’s impossible to disagree that these sportsmen are the best in their field.

These quarterbacks have started at least one game for the New York Giants of the National Football League.

Here is our Top 5 Pick for the Best Quarterbacks in New York Giants History.

1. Eli Manning

The Giants were the team where Eli Manning made his professional football debut. Having played for New York for the entirety of his 16-year career, he has decided to retire in January 2020. His total record is only passable, with 117 victories and 117 defeats. The finest quarterback the Giants have ever had is probably Eli Manning. For the Giants, he threw the ball in 248 regular-season and postseason games, the most in the team’s history.

2. Phil Simms

Phil Simms led the team to two Super Bowls – XXI and XXV – during his time with the team.
For most of his 15-year NFL career, Phil Simms played quarterback for the New York Giants. Simms played in 164 regular-season games with the Giants between 1979 and 1993, starting 159 of them despite several injuries.

3. Y.A. Tittle

Tittle made the Pro Bowl in each of his first three seasons with the Giants, and he led the NFL in throwing touchdowns in 1962 and 1963. Only four of Y.A. Tittle’s 17-year Hall of Fame career was spent with the New York Giants. However, despite the fact that the New York Giants lost three consecutive NFL championship games from 1961 to 1963, Tittle is renowned for his impressive stats that still stand up today.

4. Charlie Conerly

Throughout his 14-year NFL career, Charlie Conerly played for the New York Giants. He started out as a halfback and later transitioned to quarterback for most of his career, playing in 161 games. In 1948, he threw for 2,175 yards and 22 touchdowns, which were both second-best in the NFL.

6. Kerry Collins

Kerry Collins spent 17 seasons in the NFL with six different teams. He started 68 games at quarterback for the Giants in five seasons and twice guided them to the playoffs. New York’s  Giants 2000 NFC title team relied heavily on Collins, who had a rough start to the season. Collins was a great offensive leader, despite the fact that the defense was given much of the credit for the team’s success.